6. Was Mary a virgin before and after Jesus' birth
The Bible speaks of "brothers and sisters" of Jesus (Mt 13:56-57). But the
Catholic Church teaches that Jesus had no blood brothers or sisters and
that his Mother Mary always remained a virgin. These truths have been
arrived at from the Bible and from sacred Tradition.
Even today "brothers and sisters" may be used in many ways. When we hear
speakers address audiences as "brothers and sisters," we assume that the
words refer not to blood relatives, but to friends or to members of a
particular nation, group, or race. In the Old Testament, "brothers and
sisters" might refer to members of the same tribe (Dt 15:12) or race
(Dt 23:7), or to nephews (Gn 13:8), cousins (Lv 10:4), or relatives in
general (2 Kgs 10:13).
In the New Testament, two of those who are called brothers of Jesus, namely
James and Joseph (Mt 13:56-57), are later identified as sons of another
woman (Mt 27:56). The word "brothers" is often used for the followers of
Jesus. For example, the risen Jesus asked Mary Magdalene to "go to my
brothers." Mary "went and announced to the disciples, 'I have seen the
Lord'" (Jn 20:17-18). Jesus said that those who do the will of his Father
are his brothers (Lk 8:21), and in the New Testament, believers are called
"brothers" more than 100 times.
The New Testament never speaks of other children of Mary or Joseph, so it
is impossible to prove from the Bible that Jesus actually had blood
brothers or sisters. If there had been such blood brothers, it is
difficult to explain why Jesus, as he hung on the cross, would have given
Mary into the care of the beloved disciple. "When Jesus saw his mother and
the disciple there whom he loved, he said to his mother, 'Woman, behold,
your Son.' Then he said to the disciple, 'Behold, your mother.' And from
that hour the disciple took her into his home" (Jn 19:26-27). If Mary had
other children, it seems that they would have cared for her.
Some people think that the expression found in Mt 1:24-25 (see also Lk 2:7)
referring to Jesus as Mary's "first born" implies that Mary must have had
children after Jesus. But "first born" was a legal term for Jewish people:
the "first born" was to be presented in the Temple, as Jesus was
(Luke 2:22; see Exodus 13:2). "First born" does not imply that there was a
"second born," for there are ancient documents stating that a mother "died
in giving birth to her first-born Son."
Some people have a problem with the expression in modern English
translations that Joseph "had no relations with her until she bore a Son,
and he named him Jesus" (New American Bible translation). Our English word
"until" implies "only up to and not beyond," but the Aramaic word Jesus
used usually meant "up to" without ruling out the beyond. The word
"until" in English suggests that Joseph did have relations with Mary after
the birth of Jesus. But the Aramaic expression behind the New Testament
Greek does not suggest either that he did or that he didn't. It focuses
only on the time up to the birth of Jesus and says nothing about what
happened after. There is a similar expression in 2 Samuel 6:23 where it is
said that Michol was "childless to the day of her death"...The New American
Bible uses "to" instead of "until," but the Semitic expression behind both
phrases is the same: and obviously Michol did not have children after her
death.
A New Testament passage which clarifies this usage of "until" is Matthew
28:20, where Jesus says, "I am with you always, until the end of the age."
Here Jesus obviously means that he will be with us until the end of the
world and beyond the end of the world...that is, forever.
Further, if Jesus actually had blood brothers and sisters, it would be
difficult to explain why the Church would have denied their existence. The
most plausible reason why the Church has always held that Jesus was an only
child is that he actually was an only child!
Early Christian writers agreed that Jesus had no blood brothers and sisters
and that Mary remained a virgin. St. Jerome (345-420) wrote that
"Ignatius, Polycarp, Irenaeus, Justin Martyr and all the other learned men
going back to apostolic times" testified to the perpetual virginity of
Mary. Our Catholic belief, therefore, goes back to the earliest days of
the Church and has been a constant belief for almost 2,000 years. Since
the Holy Spirit guides the Church, we can believe that the Holy Spirit led
believers to the fact of Mary's perpetual virginity.
This fact points to the uniqueness of Jesus as the only Son of God. The
Bible states that Mary was a virgin when she conceived Christ by the power
of the Holy Spirit (Lk 1:31-35). The tradition of the Church teaches that
Mary remained a virgin. Why? Because she and Joseph witnessed the miracle
of Jesus' conception and birth. They realized that God had entrusted them
with the greatest treasure in the history of the world, God's only Son.
They understood that their task in life was to nurture and protect the
Savior of the human race. Many years later, Jesus would speak of those who
renounced marriage "for the sake of the kingdom of heaven" (Mt 19:12). It
cannot be surprising that Mary and Joseph would have wanted to renounce
their right to have other children in order to dedicate their lives to the
care of God's Son.
The Church's belief in the perpetual virginity of Mary is significant
because of what it says about Jesus and about us. The fact that Jesus was
Mary's only child underlines his uniqueness as the only Son of God. The
fact that Jesus was Mary's only child results in a special relationship
between Mary and us. Since we are the Body of Christ (1 Cor 12:27), Mary
is our Mother, and she has the same Mother's love for us that she has for
Jesus. Jesus says to us as beloved disciples, "Behold, your mother."
These facts, rooted in the Bible and clarified by the Church's tradition,
help us to see Christ in the clearest possible light. They help us to know
Mary as the Virgin Mother of Jesus and as our Virgin Mother. These
beliefs, old as the New Testament and new as today, have enriched the lives
of countless generations of Catholics.
|